JURISDICTIONAL TERRITORY AND DECISIONAL INEQUALITY: ISONOMY AS A DIMENSION OF THE CITIZEN’S SPACE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.30749/2594-8261.v10n1p246-281Abstract
This article proposes a territorial reading of decisional inequality in Brazilian civil procedure, based on Milton Santos' theoretical framework on territory and citizenship. It argues that the territorial organization of jurisdiction turns place into a determining variable of the definitive content of each litigant's rights, so that subjects in essentially identical factual and legal positions receive, by reason of the judicial district or adjudicating body to which their claims were assigned, opposite decisions on the merits, both protected by res judicata. This configuration reproduces, within the institutional space of Justice, the phenomenon Milton Santos called the mutilated citizen, whose worth before the legal order depends on location rather than condition. The article traces the trajectory of the concept of access to justice, from Cappelletti and Garth's renovating waves to Watanabe's fair legal order and Boaventura de Sousa Santos' critique, to demonstrate that the evolution of the concept requires substantial equality of outcomes between parallel cases. It examines Theme 1075 of General Repercussion, which declared unconstitutional the territorial limitation of collective res judicata, as jurisprudential recognition that territory is an inadmissible criterion of differentiation, and demonstrates the structural insufficiency of the precedent system to correct contradictory res judicata consolidated outside any binding thesis
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors retain the copyright and grant the journal right of first publication, with the work is simultaneously licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, which allows sharing the work with recognition of its authorship and initial publication in this journal.
Authors are authorized to assume additional contracts separately, for non-exclusive distribution of the version of the work published in this journal (eg, publishing in institutional repository or as a book chapter), with acknowledgment of authorship and initial publication in this journal.
The author declares to be responsible for the originality, uniqueness and currency of the article content, by means of complete references to all consulted sources.
Each author grants to the LexCult Journal permission to evaluate, normalize, edit and publish the submitted article, in an unprecedented way.
Plagiarism cases and self plagiarism will not be accepted under no circumstances. The plagiarist will be prohibited to publish in LexCult Journal for 5 years.
The copy, in full or to some extent, of an article published in LexCult Journal will be allowed as long as the source (author and Journal) is informed, being forbidden the commercial use and the production and distribution of derivative works. In case the exclusivity clause is broken, the submission will be filed and the author will be prohibited to publish in LexCult Journal for 5 years, without bringing any civil actions provided by national law.
The author is aware that:
a) Submissions may be rejected if the journal's Editorial Board, responsible for evaluation and article selection, does not consider it pertinent for publication, whatever may be the well-justified reasons;
b) Editors reserve the right to modify the submitted manuscript - without any content alteration - in view of its normalization and adaptation to the publication norms.